The Scariest The Scariest: British Nurse & American Werewolf Written by John Stanley on May 28, 2016 More in The Scariest: The Scariest: Ash to Ashes May 28, 2016 The Scariest: Skeletons Out of the Closet May 28, 2016 The Scariest: Bruce Campbell Makes an Ash of Himself May 28, 2016 One of the scariest moments in An American Werewolf in London was when a beautiful nurse (Jenny Agutter) held David Naughton’s nose shut while forcing the hapless chap to eat something he probably had no appetite for . . . the tasteless worst! I was chomping at the bit to stop her, fighting myself tooth and nail, but she didn’t listen to my screams during the premiere screening.